I have to share this amazing eyeliner! Maybelline Master Precise by Eyestudio. It’s easy to apply like a pencil but has the look and feel of liquid. A cat-eye is amazingly easy with this. I do my top line with this and line my lower eye with a waterproof liner (right now I’m using a liner from Mally). It only takes me minutes to do my eyeliner thanks to this product! Highly recommended!